II · D12 · 12.2
Companion apps for the elderly
Isolation reduction vs displacement of human care.
Major · 4Widely observedNowRisk 16
Severity
4/5
Likelihood
4/5
In the hierarchy
- Part II: Societal & Human Concerns
- D12. Human–Computer Interaction Harms
- 12.2 Anthropomorphism, companionship & attachment
Virtues and principles to explore
Held as inquiry, not as a verdict.
Dignity
Center principle
Every person is a protagonist, not a data point.
Listening
Trust
Listen to understand, rather than listen to speak.
Seeing potential
Hope
Ask what people could become with these tools, not whom they replace.
Starter questions
Written to probe curiosity and learning, not accusation.
- 01What is already being done about this, and by whom — and how would we find out without assuming?
- 02What conversation have we not yet had about this — and who needs to be in it?
- 03Who is served by addressing this, and who benefits if we leave it unnamed?
- 04Whose experience of Companion apps for the elderly is not yet in the room — and how would we hear it?
Also on this branch
Frameworks and sources
- NIST AI 600-1 Generative AI Profileframework
Writing and incidents
Open indexes first. Then, if you wish, ask Grok to search the live web for this concern — one request, cached for the rest of this session.
What happens between a person and a system: overreliance, loneliness, lost judgement.